Re: "...new ecological problem [sic]: a rapid spread of

Betsy Levy (blevy@mail.utexas.edu)
Mon, 07 Sep 1998 14:09:19 -0500

I don't get this - a colossal joke? Most annoying is that it doesn't
explain how trees contribute to global warming (or who the heck Prof. Steve
Jones is), only that they supposedly enjoy it. Periodical burning in
pre-industrial America doesn't mean fires were necessarily set - could be
they just weren't religiously suppressed, as the park service is finally
learning is a lousy idea.

No mention of trees decimated by acid rain, though, as in the Black Forest.
Also, trees sequester carbon, which many people believe is a crucial
element in any effort to capture and contain carbon dioxide and slow
greenhouse warming. Maybe I just don't have a sense of humor -? Or maybe
Chad's just trying to get a rise? Guess it worked.

At 06:29 PM 9/5/98 -0700, Beth von Gunten wrote:
> VIEW FROM THE LAB: WHY TREES MUST GET THE CHOP
>London Daily Telegraph
>3 September
>Internet:
>http://www.telegraph.co.uk/et?ac=000647321007942&rtmo=wnllAA5b&atmo=99999999
>&pg=/et/98/9/3/ecrlab05.html
>
>Prof Steve Jones has a unique solution to solving the world's global
>warming problems
>
>NEXT week's great extravaganza of science, the meeting of the British
>Association for the Advancement of Science at Cardiff, has (among
>sessions on "The Day the Sun Goes Out", "Computers in Engineering" and
>"Exploding Custard") a whole morning devoted to "Forestry: A Growing
>Challenge". The message is simple - England, the barest country in
>Europe, needs more trees.
>
>The real issue, though, is not too few of those leafy objects, but too
>many. Scientists are warning of a new ecological problem: a rapid
>spread of forests that is threatening the world's landscapes.
>
>Some mistake, there, surely? We all know that the rainforest is being
>destroyed, and that the fires around Athens this summer were the worst
>there have ever been. In many places, though, timber is not in retreat,
>but in swift advance. In my favourite bolt-hole in southern France the
>markets sell photographs of the villages taken from old postcards. They
>are bought mainly by locals, who look wistfully at streets without S-
>reg Volvos or mime-artists, but the biggest change is not in the people
>but in the scenery.
>
>Fifty years ago, the rocky hills of Languedoc were almost bare because
>they were grazed by sheep or terraced into tiny vineyards. Now, the
>land has been abandoned; and, in some places, the amount of cover has
>gone up by 15 times. The trees are taking over, and there are thousands
>of acres of oak and pine on what was once farmland. The same is true
>all over southern Europe, and the great Mediterranean Forest is today
>bigger than it has been for centuries.
>
>Ecologists are alarmed: birds such as the Dartford Warbler, the Serin,
>the Stonechat and the Linnet - all inhabitants of open scrub - are in
>rapid retreat and are being replaced by common woodland birds found
>throughout Europe. The Black Wheatear, a lover of rocky places, was
>declared extinct in France two years ago. The scrublands of the
>Mediterranean contain 20,000 species of flowering plant, most of which
>die as soon as they are shaded out. Some nature-lovers are calling for
>the fires to be allowed to burn to rescue the flowers and the birds
>from their gloomy fate.
>
>Trees are galloping across the United States, too. A recent meeting of
>the Ecological Society of America heard that, with global warming,
>there are more summer rains in the deserts of the south-west, and that
>this "Arizona monsoon" is predicted to increase over the next century.
>A simple experiment on watering the shrubby oaks that dot the hillsides
>shows that, when it does, they will produce three times as many
>seedlings as before.
>
>The greenhouse effect comes, of course, from carbon dioxide in the
>atmosphere, up by a third since the Industrial Revolution. That gas,
>too, stimulates tree growth; and a test on Texas trees shows that the
>increase above natural levels likely within the next century will
>double the number of plants that survive. If that is not enough, the
>other great air pollutant, nitrogen, does its bit. There is plenty of
>it in car exhausts, and it falls miles away from the cities, spurring
>the growth of distant forests.
>
>The Volvo as the friend of the tree means that a third of America's
>open deserts and scrub may soon be covered by forest. That causes
>concern; not just because the Lone Ranger will have to carry a machete,
>but because the country's precious national parks are threatened. No
>doubt, the sound of the conservationist's chain-saw will soon be heard
>in the land.
>
>However, the woody plague hit the United States long before air
>pollution. In the Shenandoah Valley, in Virginia, growth rings in the
>largest trunks show that, at the time of the Indians, fires were set
>every five years or so. Many of the early travellers commented on the
>park-like landscape, with open grasslands and not much standing timber.
>Today's Shenandoah National Park, though, is in the main an
>impenetrable, and strictly protected, woodland.
>
>Trees are inexorable things, always ready to take over as soon as they
>get the chance. At the end of the last ice age, seeds preserved in peat
>show that spruce and pine followed the glaciers northwards at a mile a
>year - which means that Birnam Wood could easily have marched on
>Dunsinane (some 10 miles away) within Macbeth's lifetime.
>
>Something must be done to stop the forests before it is too late. The
>message that the British Association should pass on to the ecology
>movement is clear: Save the Planet! Chop Down a Tree!
>
>from the climate change list: <climate-l@mbnet.mb.ca>
>
>Chad Carpenter
>International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD)
>New York, NY
>Tel: + 1 (212) 643-9599
>Fax: +1 (212) 644-0206
>E-mail: chadc@iisd.org
>Internet: http://www.iisd.ca/linkages/chad/chad.html
>Linkages Journal: http://www.iisd.ca/linkages/journal/
>
>
>
>To Unsubscribe: Email majordomo@ces.ncsu.edu with "unsubscribe sanet-mg".
>To Subscribe to Digest: Email majordomo@ces.ncsu.edu with the command
>"subscribe sanet-mg-digest".
>

To Unsubscribe: Email majordomo@ces.ncsu.edu with "unsubscribe sanet-mg".
To Subscribe to Digest: Email majordomo@ces.ncsu.edu with the command
"subscribe sanet-mg-digest".